Why did Mr. Godwin think Mary’s writing was an imitator? This question has intrigued literary scholars for centuries, as it delves into the complex relationship between authorship and originality. Mary Shelley, known for her groundbreaking novel “Frankenstein,” has often been criticized for her writing style, which some believe lacks originality and is heavily influenced by other authors of her time. In this article, we will explore the reasons behind Mr. Godwin’s perception of Mary’s writing and the impact it had on her literary career.
Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein” was published in 1818, and it quickly gained popularity among readers and critics alike. However, it was not long before the novel faced accusations of plagiarism and imitation. One of the most prominent critics who accused Mary of copying was her own father, William Godwin. As a leading philosopher and writer, Godwin held a significant influence on his daughter’s work, and his disapproval of her writing style was a significant blow to her reputation.
William Godwin’s main argument was that Mary’s writing was derivative of the works of other authors, particularly those of her contemporaries. He pointed out that many elements of “Frankenstein” were reminiscent of the works of her close friends, such as Percy Bysshe Shelley and Lord Byron. For instance, the concept of the monster’s creation through electricity was inspired by Lord Byron’s poem “The Giaour,” which mentioned the use of lightning to animate a statue.
Moreover, Godwin believed that Mary’s writing lacked the depth and sophistication of her father’s own works. He argued that her characters were one-dimensional and that her narrative was overly simplistic. This criticism was particularly damaging, as Mary was often seen as a successor to her father’s literary legacy. Godwin’s perception of her writing as imitative and inferior to his own work cast a long shadow over her reputation and hindered her recognition as a unique and original author.
However, it is essential to note that Mary Shelley’s writing was not without its merits. “Frankenstein” remains a classic novel that has influenced countless works in literature and film. Mary’s exploration of themes such as science, morality, and the human condition has made her a significant figure in the literary world. Despite Godwin’s accusations, Mary’s unique voice and imagination are undeniable.
In conclusion, the question of why Mr. Godwin thought Mary’s writing was an imitator highlights the challenges faced by female authors during the 19th century. Mary Shelley’s literary career was not without its struggles, as she often had to defend her work against accusations of plagiarism and imitation. While Godwin’s criticism was undoubtedly hurtful, it is crucial to recognize the originality and depth of Mary’s writing. Her novel “Frankenstein” stands as a testament to her creativity and has left an indelible mark on the literary world.
